Number Four. David Crowder Band – A Collision (September 27, 2005)
An old gospel choir sings in a slow, melancholy tone: “Soon I will be done with the troubles of the world…” The old hymn fades into the second movement – an acoustic guitar picking over a restrained percussive backbeat, and you can almost feel the dark clouds roll in. The frontman’s voice adds to the driving build-up: “How long…… ’til you hear us?” The refrain wafts along until fading again, with only the long, sad note of a violin carrying over. Suddenly all is cut off with a quick drum hit that ushers in the wild and frisky banjo. The dark clouds are lifted with an abundance of handclaps and rejoicing. “Lift up your heads, lift up your heads…” What crazy mastermind is behind this unexpected welding of gospel, electronica, and hillbilly-bluegrass into a seamless work of art? And that’s just two of the twenty-one tracks! What genius can concoct an old country version of a classic hymn, a cover of a Sufjan Stevens song, a movement from a classical composer, and a song with electronic loops that gets played on Contemporary Christian radio – and fit it all on one album with a unified theme? The one and only David Crowder…
I was introduced to Crowder in high school by hearing “O Praise Him” on the CCM radio. I gently mocked his slightly shaking voice, completely unaware of the worship juggernaut he would become – and the importance he would have in redefining worship in my life.
I divide my paradigms about worship into three distinct phases. The first was my childhood, where I didn’t really understand what made those songs different than any other song. The second period started in junior high, where under youth pastor Mark Willis I gained an understanding that these songs were being sung to God. My favorite songs were the ones that were surrendering to God or asking him for strength and growth, but I didn’t much care for the ones that just declared things about God being strong or holy or whatever. I mean, yeah, that’s true, but I thought worship was about singing to God, not just about him.
It was at the beginning of my college years that I began to gain an understanding of that true nature of praise, as I began to see more and more evidence of God’s provision and faithfulness in my life and the lives of those around me. The simplest lines of a song or a Scripture would fill me with great joy, not because of the verse or song itself but because of the truth reflected in the verse. I struggled to explain these feelings, often with romantic metaphors.
The song that most completely captured this paradigm for me was one I first heard at a Friday night youth worship service I attended for awhile in my first year of college. I didn’t even know “You Are My Joy” was by David Crowder at that time; I just knew it fully represented the joy that filled me: “And I cannot hold it in, and remain composed / Love’s taken over me, so I propose / The letting myself go, I am letting myself go / You are my joy, you are my joy, you are my joy, you are my joy!”
Ian McIntosh’s Awakened is the epitome of that third phase for me, but I might not have been able to receive that album in the same manner had David Crowder not paved the way. I believe it was not until my longtime friends and roommates Garrett and Sam were singing and trying to play that song on guitar that I realized it was actually a David Crowder song. I then realized that I already knew a few other songs from the same album, and, buoyed by Garrett’s hearty recommendation, I began to check out the entirety of A Collision.
In addition to the expressions of joyful praise found in “You Are My Joy” and several other songs, this album also represents the height of creativity in songwriting. I hinted at the genre-bending in the opening paragraph. David Crowder is obsessed with the looping software known as Reason, and he mixes in his electronic loops with their real drummer and all of the other instruments without sounding, uh, crowded, even when they keep slipping in and out of bluegrass, gospel, and so forth. The album flows very well, changing and growing and building and maintaining your interest as it unfolds, despite its 72 minutes (unlike their latest opus, Church Music, which for the most part feels like an hour of “Can You Feel It?” on repeat). Even the interlude tracks are better than a lot of bands’ regular tracks. (“Be.. more… quiet now… and wait… for… a voice to say…“)
The album’s flow is enhanced by its intricate symbolism, some of which is explained in an “interview” at the end of the album, and some of which can only be explained by Garrett, who somehow has access to information I cannot find anywhere on the Internet. A Collision is about death and rebirth, framed around a motif that represents a rising lark from a piece from classical composer Vaughn Williams… it’s about this collision between Divinity and depravity that raises us from our depths, in spite of our inadequate understandings and responses… it’s something about the old symbol of an atom that we now know doesn’t really represent what an atom looks like. “What we mean to say is that the elements of worship are inadequate, much like the atom depiction,” Crowder says. “But this is what we have, you know? It helps us carry the idea.” Garrett can wax prolific about the unfolding moods and themes of the album through the ordering of the songs (and his explanations actually don’t sound too far-fetched).
The passion that David Crowder pours into his craft, and his desire for excellence, is truly inspiring. And yet, in spite of all this grand posturing, Crowder and Co. refrain from taking themselves too seriously. The mock-animé evil-squirrel music video for “Foreverandever, Etc” ranks among my all-time favorites, and the story behind it is a classic example of Crowder’s subtle sense of humor.
Last but not least, A Collision represents a link among us four roommates and our college years. Despite each of our varied tastes and preferences, A Collision is a rare album that all four of us completely enjoy. And what is worship if it does not have unity?
Thanks, David Crowder, for helping us use what we have. That’s why you’re sitting at Number Four.
My Most Important Albums Of The Decade
Week of 10/18 – Honorable Mentions (#14-#11)
Week of 10/25 – #10. Lord of the Rings
Week of 11/1 – #9. How To Save A Life
Week of 11/8 – #8. The Beautiful Letdown
Week of 11/15 – #7. Awakened
Week of 11/22 – #6. MMHMM
Week of 11/29 – #5. The Alchemy Index
Week of 12/6 – #4. A Collision
Week of 12/13 – #3. Brother, Sister
Week of 12/20 – #2. Define The Great Line
Week of 12/27 – #1. All The Houses Look The Same